6 Comments
User's avatar
Celine Nguyen's avatar

This was deeply enjoyable to read—both because of your intriguing summary/analysis of the novel, and because I've really enjoyed Naomi Kanakia's essays and questions of found family vs biological family, envying bourgeois stability, and queer/trans stories that delve into the tangled and complicated parts of those identities!

Love your closing quote from Samuel R. Delany as well…such a wonderful articulation of how novels map out the choices and outcomes of human lives. Thank you for writing this review!!

Expand full comment
John Pistelli's avatar

You're welcome—very glad you enjoyed it! I definitely think you'll like the book.

Expand full comment
Naomi Kanakia's avatar

I'm a HUGE Heinlein fan. I read dozens of his books growing up, and Starship Troopers and Moon is a Harsh Mistress very much held up on adult re-reads. I deeply admired his ability to create utopias with radically different political valences, from the libertarian to the fascist to the hippy, without any of it seeming like a mere thought experiment

Expand full comment
John Pistelli's avatar

I also grew up reading him—Stranger in a Strange Land blew my 11-year-old mind! That's what Delany praises him for too: a genuine political savvy expressed artfully in narrative, irrespective of his own beliefs.

Expand full comment
Mary Jane Eyre's avatar

The crossover event I’ve been waiting for! Great review: it’s motivated me to inch it up my to-read list.

Expand full comment
John Pistelli's avatar

Thank you! I think you'll enjoy it.

Expand full comment